Schwartz Again with Dr. Irfan this time!

Schwartz Again with Dr. Irfan this time!

Everyone’s “favourite” neo-con Muslim and self-styled sufi and protector of Muslims against “radicalism”, Stephen Schwartz is at it again in another attack on Shaykh Hamza and Zaytuna College with a swipe at Imam Zaid.  This is becoming tiresome and boring.

Disappointingly, he is joined this time by Dr. Irfan Alawi (not the same as the webmaster who is a different person entirely) who had previously denied, on a number of occasions, any slandering and maligning of Shaykh Hamza and of any direct association with Schwartz. However this time he has written a joint article, in which Schwarts spews his bile and regurgitates the same tired old and firmly debunked myths about Shaykh Hamza. The whole piece reeks of envy, diseased hearts and obsessed minds.

SubhanAllah, it is an understatement to say that Shaykh Hamza and Imam Zaid have changed the lives of thousands, and it is no exaggeration that they have illuminated this world with their works, speech and presence, they never sought fame or repute. I have personally witnessed and spent time with both these men in public and in private and all I have seen is goodness, they are the same in private as they are in public, they are utterly gracious when it comes to criticism and unhesitatingly forgiving when wronged.  Allah chooses whom He wills to carry out His Divine work and who better in the West than Shaykh Hamza and Imam Zaid. What have the likes of the detractors of these great men actually achieved apart from a few pieces of lazy and sensationalist journalism and a few slide-shows on the disappearing sacred heritage of Saudi Arabia, whose lives have they changed for the better, what positive representation of Islam and Muslims have they given?

I am extremely disappointed with Dr. Irfan who has always stated he has nothing against Shaykh Hamza and I have always given him the benefit of the doubt even though some very credible and trustworthy people have pointed out a few things that troubled me regarding him. I have been acquainted with Dr. Irfan since the mid-90s and I have had a few run-ins with him over a misunderstanding or two but our relationship has remained largely cordial.

Anyway, the caravan moves on despite the noise from the proverbial sidelines. May Allah continue to grant Shaykh Hamza, Imam Zaid and all of our noble shayukh long lives and health to keep on doing what they are doing, illuminating our hearts and nourishing our minds. To borrow a phrase from the Bible “by their fruits ye shall know them” – and we have consistently enjoyed beautiful fruits from these beautiful people. The only thing we can do, as per the instruction of our Shayukh, is make dua for these people, and ask Allah to turns their hearts to what is good and forgive them their short comings.

The article appears in the link below, if you care to read it, I have not hyperlinked it as I don’t want to contribute to its page rank so you’ll have to copy and paste it.

4 thoughts on “Schwartz Again with Dr. Irfan this time!

  1. Assalamu Alaikum,

    I think he’s just jealous that he’s not as famous or influential as Sh. Hamza et al.

    Honestly, this kind of mindset is just so warped that one cannot even begin to fathom it.

  2. As-Salaamu ‘alaikum,

    Irfan Alawi has been his side man for years, or at least Schwartz claims he has been. Part of me still doesn’t want to believe it since Irfan got me seriously interested in the Haba’ib back in 1998. This is par for Steve’s miserable course.

  3. Assalamu Alaikum,

    I think he’s just jealous that he’s not as famous or influential as Sh. Hamza et al.

    Honestly, this kind of mindset is just so warped that one cannot even begin to fathom it.

  4. Assalamu alaikum

    I for one have seen Irfan on the scence since the mid 90’s also, and he gives the impression that he is close to the family of the late Dr Muhammad ibn Alawi al-Maliki – though there is doubt that Irfan can converse in arabic let alone write in it. Secondly, Irfan is not a real Alawi (a descendant of the Holy Prophet – sallallahu alaihi wa sallam) but may be in Tariqa only; his origins appear to be Indian subcontinent but his family connections took root in Kenya then the UK if i recall.

    I am also doubtful that he has an accredited Doctorate from any recognised university that one could check his actual scholastic credentials.. Then again, he is not an Alim of the Deen. One of our teachers also heard him phone in and praise the so called efforts of the heretical Shi’ite English satellite channel called Ahlul Bayt channel on the SKY network.

    If Irfan is reading this then he can disprove all the above with evidence.


    Abu Zahra

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.