Wishing a Merry Christmas?
First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very thought of this is abhorrent to us. We don’t believe that Christ is the literal and begotten Son of God. We do, however, believe that Jesus (may peace be upon him) was a Divinely inspired Prophet and Messenger of God, a devoted and absolute servant of a Just, Merciful and Loving Lord. Like most historians and Christian historians, we know that Jesus wasn’t born on 25th December. We know that celebrations on 25th December were originally a pagan festival upon which Christianity grafted the birthday of Christ on. So, we can safely assume that all of these things we reject out of hand. What we don’t reject is the actual event of the birth of Isa (Jesus) alayhi salam. For Muslims it is as joyous and blessed an occasion as it is for our Christian brethren. It does not matter to us what day it is celebrated upon because the event itself is momentous.
As Muslims, most of us celebrate the birthday of the Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and grant him peace) even though the exact date is not agreed upon, it is commonly assumed to be the 12th of the Islamic month of Rabi al-Awwal. What our scholars have said is that the Mawlid, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, should be celebrated throughout the year as well as on the date commonly believed to be the day the Prophet was born. We find in many Muslim cultural traditions, spontaneous celebrations of the Mawlid on joyous occasions such as the birth of children, marriages or any event that was of good fortune. Islamic dates are based upon the lunar calendar so the Islamic months drift across the solar calendar and seasons, so for me, the argument over the date is a very minor issue.
So with this in mind we can proceed.
As a Muslim living in the West, I interact with people of all faiths and traditions. I also interact with people of no formal faith as well as atheists. In most cases our relationships are cordial and civil and many of my acquaintances respect my religious views. In other cases we make very meaningful friendships with people of other traditions and beliefs and share in each other’s occasions of happiness and grief. When Ramadan or Eid come around my neighbours, friends and colleagues go out of their way to wish me a happy Eid or Ramadan. Wishing someone a Merry Christmas no more makes me a believer in their ways than them wishing me a Happy Eid or Eid Mubarak makes them a believer in Islam, to suggest or think otherwise is ludicrous. It is common courtesy and good manners, is it not, that when my friends, colleagues and neighbours have their moments of joy and happiness that I reciprocate? Can you imagine the impression it would give of Muslims and Islam, if, when such occasions came around for them, I remained silent and mean spirited and not acknowledge their occasion of joy and happiness?
What occasion is more “religious†than a funeral? Did our Prophet (Allah bless him and grant him peace) not stand out of respect for a funeral procession of a Jewish man and acknowledge it? Additionally, the Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and grant him peace) adopted the fasting of Ashura when he observed that the Jews were fasting in order to commemorate the deliverance of Moses and the Children of Israel from the tyranny of the Pharaoh. He said that we had more right to this commemoration than the Jews did and the fasting of Ashura was instituted.
I can say that in my personal life, non-Muslims friends and acquaintances have always shown me and my faith respect, they have go out of their way to help me. When I was working for a large pharmaceutical company, I used to use a conference room for prayer. I asked the department secretary to block book 10 minute slots for me so that I could offer my prayers. She did this without hesitation and always notified me of any changes and would accommodate me. The conference room was later turned into offices and I lost my prayer space. I mentioned this to one of the managers, she was an atheist, and I also mentioned it to one of the directors in our building, he was a Christian. Both of these wonderful people went above and beyond the call of duty to find me an alternative space to pray in. They could have turned around and said “sorry Masud, we can’t help you†and that would have been that, but no, they considered it a duty to help me. They eventually found for me a very small area, just large enough to accommodate a prayer mat and they apologised profusely for not being able to find me a space a little larger and a little better. I was, and still am, utterly grateful to them for this incredible generosity of spirit and respect they showed me and my faith. How then can I not have a magnanimity of spirit to people of other faiths?
Many Muslims, in their religiosity, seem to dispense with common sense. This is not as big an issue that many make it out to be. Every year, come Christmas time, we get the usually sombre and stern messages from people warning us not to wish anyone a merry Christmas. In reality though, it boils down to manners and being civil with people and this does not mean that we accept their beliefs, rather, we accept that people have beliefs different to ours and we wish them happiness on their occasions of happiness.
62 thoughts on “Wishing a Merry Christmas?”
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
Ali Qamar liked this on Facebook.
Hifsa Iqbal liked this on Facebook.
Aston Walker liked this on Facebook.
Nadir Khan liked this on Facebook.
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
@masudcouk Mawlid-un-Nabi Mubarak
@masudcouk Uncle Mas I’m pleased to have read this, JazakAllahu khayr. There was much controversy on Twitter last night…
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
@masudcouk you can still celebrate his birth, besides its part of our culture outside of religion
RIGHT: so simply saying so should not be taken as an automatic acceptance of Christian theology just as the Prophet Alayhissalaam extended the Christian delegation from Najran to not only stay in the Masjid but PRAY in it also … the Prophet ALayhissalaam had repudiated the theology but permitted the prayer … for those who say the greeting is an encouragement of their Kufr – then what of the Prophet Alayhissalaam who went as far as permitting their ritual acts of worship?
🙂
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
@masudcouk bro what do you think abt some mslms merrying a happy xmas to cristians?
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
a very good point…..
Khalid Maricar liked this on Facebook.
Shahrukh Qadri liked this on Facebook.
Iskandar Soekardi liked this on Facebook.
Omar El Gomati liked this on Facebook.
Zak Khan liked this on Facebook.
Shereen Aziz-Williams liked this on Facebook.
RT @masudcouk: Wishing a Merry Christmas?: First things first. We are Muslims. We don’t believe that Christ is God, the very th… http: …
I no longer get the stern and somber messages to refrain from telling people to have a happy Christmas. This is because I no longer have Wahabbis in my friends list. Hehehe
there’s a difference between permissibility of doing something and the wisdom of doing something. Wishing Christians Merry Christmas and the like is not really good dawah or even necessary for friendly relations
Not everything that we do must be done purely in the name of “dawah.” I also disagree with the sentiment that giving good tidings is not necessary for friendly relations. Speaking from a firsthand experience, I know what a world it makes to have someone who is not your coreligionist, wish you a happy holiday. When my non-Muslim co-workers would tell me “Happy Eid,” I was always thrilled. I felt that they respected and appreciated me. Likewise, I felt it necessary to return the favor, and tell them to have a happy Christmas. It was only right and fair to do so. I have always felt that the best for of “dawah” is to simply be kind to those around us, whether they be Muslim or not. It speaks volumes when people can see that we Muslims are kind hearted people who truly care. What good is it to start preaching away about what the Quran says, if we are never living what the Quran says? The Quran tells us to respect the People of the Book. By saying, “Merry Christmas,” and “Happy Hanukkah,” we are doing just that. It doesn’t mean that we believe what they believe. It just means that we wish them well, and would like for them to wish us well in return.
mashallah Inaya Shujaat. This saudi/najdi/slafi/munafiq dawah business is the peak of a lack of empathy. Besides most of my family aint muslim and my mom isnt muslim so all the ‘najdi dawah’ saudis can just go to hell.
Thank you Inaya Shujaat. Very well put
Dawah is of the utmost importance but as a former Christian those expressions of sentiment do nothing in terms of opening people to Islam. Also there’s a difference of returning a greeting and initiating one. Being polite in a return exchange is one thing but initiating it is a subtle encouragement of there practice.
My family isn’t muslim either, Ashton, do you feel some sort of pressure to go out of your way to wish Merry Christmas?
more islam fascist babble. Ahmad humans are not childlike beings and you sir are not Allahs enforcer. Be a warner not a warder. We’re all sinners here geezer 😉
I barely go out of my way to practise some good deeds being a sinner and a wretch. Only Allah can pardon ones sin. You commit sins right Ahmad? or are you some sort of sinnless being…..
and why the hell do people call me ‘Ashton’ when clearly my name is Aston. Mashallah.
How does your reply jell with what i posted. Where did I imply enforcing anything. We’re all just giving perspectives and life experiences.
What does sin have to do with what i posted. No one even implied a sin. Sorry about the name btw.
Look geezer its all about sin. if you are a sinless character then by all means dawah away. Dawah is a lofty calling. Not really meant for self righteous munafiqs.
Common sense and good Adaab such as courtesy and kindness should be the hallmarks of a Muslim. Thank you for this excellent piece!
So only sinless people can do dawah? And why do you call me outside of my name?
Ahmad if you don’t want to say merry Xmas, that’s fine, but then don’t condemn others to shirk for saying so.
whatever. dawah is a lofty calling not for weak willed puny human beings who want to bully the debate about spreading a little christian charity. I sing in a choir in a church guess that makes me a kafir huh? Grow up Ahmad you aint no right hand of Allah to be telling anyone a damn thing about what greetings of peace to extend.
Khalida Khan liked this on Facebook.
Bodrul Islam liked this on Facebook.
Orhan Sheriff liked this on Facebook.
Riyad Karim liked this on Facebook.
Inaya Shujaat liked this on Facebook.
Rashad Ali liked this on Facebook.
Waqar and Aston your projections have no place with me. Have I mentioned anything of shirk or kufr?
no but I can smell a brainwashed saudi/najdi agent a mile off!!!! Get thee from here, for thou art a maker of mischief!!!!